Advanced search
Visit
15849
Last Updated: 2008/06/06
Summary of question
Why do we have to follow only one marja’ and how is this matter proven through hadiths?
question
Some accept the concept of Taqlid, however they question the obligation to follow only one particular marja, how can this be proven through hadiths?
Concise answer

If you are sure that each of several marja’s are experts and more learned than others in a specific field, or at least equal in knowledge and understanding, then it is okay to follow more than one marja’.

Detailed Answer

We must say that you have first assumed that the basis of your question (which says that it isn’t permissible to follow more than marja’) is correct and then have asked about the reason behind it. In contrast to what has been assumed in your question, many faqihs or fiqh experts believe that in certain cases, not only is it permissible, but it is wajib to follow more than one marja’. Therefore, we will first list some of the fatwas on this issue and the Islamic reasoning behind it.

Imam Khomeini’s judgment: If two mujtahids are equal in knowledge (and none are more learned than the other), others (who aren’t mujtahids and have to practice taqlid) can refer to any of the two that they desire, and they can also follow one of the two in some issues and the other in other issues.[1]

The Grand Ayatullah Khamenei also says: Not only isn’t tab’iz (following a mujtahid in some issues and another in other ones) problematic, but if there are marja’s that are each more learned than others in certain subjects of fiqh, it is necessary and wajib to follow each in the field that he is an expert in.[2] Another viewpoint is that if there are two mujtahids in which one is an expert in worship while the other is an expert in transactions, it is necessary as a precaution to follow both of them.[3] It has also been said that if two marja’s are equal in knowledge, one can follow any of the two that he/she chooses, and also if desired, he/she can follow one in some issues and the other in other issues.[4] Therefore, what you stated (that one can only follow one marja’) isn’t accepted by many scholars. The only important point that must be explained here is the difference between udul (changing one’s marja’ after following a certain one) and tab’iz.

In order to explain the abovementioned points further, a few points must be noted:

1- The reason behind why every individual has to follow a particular marja’ has been explained as follows:

a) We are sure that every action that we do has an Islamic ruling that has been expressed by the imams, let it be a specific ruling on the action, or a general one that the act goes under.

b) We also know that Islamic scholars and narrators of hadiths have been assigned by the imams as references of Islamic rulings and issues.[5]

c) Our hadiths haven’t assigned a particular person as the authority and official reference during the major occultation of Imam Zaman (as), what they do mention though are the characteristics of such scholars and references.

d) We can't follow all Islamic scholars, because they all don’t have the same viewpoints on various issues. We also can't follow an undistinguished scholar without knowing which one we are following, just like we can't be free and not follow anyone at all and do anything we like, because that is something that the mind won't accept and is also in contrast with what Muslims have practiced throughout history.

Hence, taking into consideration the characteristics mentioned in different hadiths, it is our duty to choose between the different individuals that meet the standards required for one to be followed, making him our marja’ taqlid.

e) After choosing the appropriate marja’ and following him in an issue, we can no longer follow another marja’ regarding that same issue. In other words, it isn’t possible to have two different taqlids regarding the same issue, unless the second marja’ has the same judgment as the first, or if one finds out that the first marja’ wasn’t qualified for being marja’ in the first place.[6]

2- The difference between tab’iz and udul:

a) Tab’iz has two instances; the first being for one to follow two or more marja’s, each being an expert in a certain field, in the field they have an expertise in, and the second being for one to follow two or more marja’s that are completely equal in all fields, each in a certain field. Of course, both of these methods of tab’iz (which are both correct), apply to cases that the individual wants to begin taqlid for the first time.

b) Udul means for one to switch to a marja’ in a certain issue (or issues) although he/she has acted according to the judgment of another marja’ on that issue. This case differs from tab’iz and most scholars don’t see this case as permissible. Imam Khomeini says: There are only two ways one can switch between two live marja’s; the first being for the second marja’ to be equal and as learned as the first, which in this case it is permissible to switch to the second (udul). The second way is for the second marja’ to be more learned than the first, making it wajib to switch to the second.[7]

Naturally, before becoming sure that the second is more learned or at least equal to the first, one cannot switch between marja’s without an acceptable reason.

Some scholars have explained the abovementioned ruling by saying that before following a marja’ in a specific ruling, it is okay to switch between marja’s (meaning that even if one has chosen a marja’ to follow, but still hasn’t followed him by acting according to his judgment, it is okay to change the marja’), but after acting according to a marja’s verdict, it is no longer permissible to change marja’s. For further information, on this matter, you can refer to Question 1335 of this website.

3- Another point that needs to be mentioned, is that in cases that one’s marja’ (that one has chosen because of him being the most learned) doesn’t have a definite fatwa on a particular issue and has issued an obligatory precaution instead (obligatory precaution refers to when a marja’ doesn’t reach a specific conclusion on a certain issue or has reached a conclusion but there are other reasons that don’t allow him to announce his viewpoint, he issues an obligatory precaution), one can refer to his/her next marja’ (which is the most learned after the first marja’) and act according to his fatwa if he has one and if not, he can refer to the next most learned and so on until a marja’ who has a definite fatwa instead of an obligatory precaution, or he/she can act according to his/her first marja’s obligatory precaution instead of referring to anyone else. Therefore, in short, in the case of one’s marja’ issuing an obligatory precaution on an issue, he/she can do one of two things; either act according to his obligatory precaution or refer to the next marja’ and follow his fatwa.[8] This method of referring to another marja’ when one’s own marja’ issues a precaution can also somewhat be considered a form of tab’iz.

4- The final necessary note is that the believers shouldn’t make the subject of following more than one marja’ an excuse to follow any marja’ they desire in any issue just because his judgment on that issue goes with what they like. For instance, if someone is a smoker, and his marja’ says that smoking doesn’t break one’s fast, there is no problem for that individual to smoke while fasting. But if that same person’s marja’ says that smoking breaks one’s fast, and he goes on to follow another marja’ that believes that it is okay to smoke while fasting, without observing the necessary criteria for being able to switch between marja's, it isn’t acceptable and in reality this act isn’t called following a marja’ or taqlid, it is merely a way of justifying one’s acts that he/she desires.[9]



[1] Seyyid Ruhullah Khomeini, Tahrirul-Wasilah, Darul-Ilm Institute, Qum, second print, vol. 1, pg. 6, issue 8.

[2] Seyyid Ali Khamenei, Ajwebatul-Istifta’at, Darul-Naba’ lil-Nashri wal-Tawzi’, first print, 1420 (ah), vol. 1, pg. 10, question 17.

[3] Seyyid Kadhim Yazdi, Al-Urwatul-Wuthqa, al-Nashrul-Islami Institute, 1404 (ah), first print, pg. 38, issue 47.

[4] Seyyid Muhsin Hakim, Mustamsakul-Urwatil-Wuthqa, Library of al-Seyyidul-Mar’ashi, 1404 (ah), vol.1, pg.?.

[5] Muhammad ibnil-Hasan Hurr al-Ameli, Wasa’elul-Shia, Aalul-Bayt Institute, Qum, 1409 (ah), vol. 27, pg. 140, hadith 33424.

[6] This reasoning is a summary of the late Ayatullah Seyyid Muhsin Hakim’s sayings in pp. 13 and 14 of the first volume of his book Mustamsakul-Urwah.

[7] Tahrirul-Wasilah, vol. 1, pg. 6, issue 4.

[8] Ibid, vol. 1, pg. 11, issue 34.

[9] There are many examples like smoking and here smoking was only mentioned as an example.

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • Does committing some sins like suicide automatically entail entering Hell?
    7539 Theoretical 2010/09/04
    Some sins, due to their quality, leave no opportunity to repent and will lead their committers to the irreversible path of Hell, the same way falling from heights without employing a parachute or landing equipment will lead to the disintegration of the body or the same way falling ...
  • What are the conditions of divorce?
    9254 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/01/11
    If you were interested in living with your husband, you should have made every effort to save the marriage. In fact, you could have done something to draw your in-laws' attention and make your husband love you. If you think you made every necessary effort, you should never think that ...
  • Whose saying is this: "Death is sweater to me than honey."
    7973 تاريخ کلام 2011/01/10
    This saying is widely ascribed to Qasim son of Imam Hasan Mujtaba (a.s.). It is said that when his beloved uncle, Imam Hussein (a.s.) asked him "My child, my nephew, tell me, how do you regard death and what do you think about getting killed?" He promptly answered: ...
  • What is Islam's viewpoint regarding reincarnation?
    14897 Traditional 2010/01/21
    A few centuries back in India a theory known as "reincarnation" was developed concerning the consecutive return of souls to this world after death. During the ages this theory was gradually taken into serious consideration by people all around the world and even became, for some, a part ...
  • Please explain the features the Quran mentions for an Imam.
    10893 Traditional 2012/01/17
    There are two types of Imamate (leadership of a society) mentioned in the Quran; First: “The Imams of light” who are the pious and righteous leaders and second: “The Imams of fire” who are the heads of Kufr (disbelief) and deviation. Many features have been mentioned ...
  • Was Hazrat Adam (P.B.U.H.) Black?
    35391 Exegesis 2006/11/25
                There are several interpretations in the Quran on the creation of man, which show that the creation of man had several stages, which were as follows:[1]  
  • Who was Salah al-Din Ayyubi? How did he become the champion of the wars against crusaders? What was his origin? Why and how did he destroy the Fatimid government?
    15602 تاريخ بزرگان 2015/08/04
    Salah al-Din Yusuf bin Ayyub who later became known as Salah al-Din Ayyubi, better known in the Western world as Saladin, is one of the most famous Muslim rulers and commanders in the Islamic middle centuries (or in the 12th century of the English calendar). He achieved ...
  • where did secularism or the belief in the separation of religious and civil affairs emerge from?
    7848 Modern 2008/11/19
    During the renascence Christian believers came to the realization that their religion, with all the shortcomings it had, could not meet the modern social and political needs; therefore, secularism took shape.Secularism can be considered as the legitimate child of western civilization since Christianity, having gotten distracted and intermingled with ...
  • What is sex change?
    8421 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/08/23
    Although dictionaries do not provide a definition for "sex change", it means any change and transformation in a male, female or genderless in such a way that the current state is different from the previous one. Medically speaking, sex change is different from "genetic modification" ...
  • What kind of a book is "Mikyalul Makarim"?
    6926 شخصیت های شیعی 2014/01/20
    The book "Mikyalul Makarim fi Fawaed al-Dua Lil-Qaem" as the title of the book reads, has been authored regarding Mahdi, the Imam of Time (atf). This is one of the books written in Arabic in the fourth hegira century.[1] The book Mikyalul Makarim consists ...

Popular