Advanced search
Last Updated: 2008/11/01
Summary of question
Is Imam\'s (A.S) asking holy Prophet (peace be upon him and his household) in contrast to Imam\'s (A.S) expansive knowledge? What is the scope of Imam\'s (A.S) knowledge according to Shia?
Shiites maintain that the Infallible Imams (peace be upon them) know what has happened and what will happen in the future and nothing is unknown to them. They also believe that [Imam] Ali (A.S) is the gate of knowledge; so how is it possible that Imam Ali (A.S) does not know the ruling for mazi [Arabic term referring the pre-cum or the fluid that is secreted as a result of foreplay prior to ejaculation] and sends someone to learn its ruling from the holy Prophet (S)?!
Concise answer
There is no disagreement among Muslims about the necessity of Imam's knowledge. However the discrepancy exists about the quantity and quality of his knowledge. Shiites believe that the Imam should, at least, have the knowledge required for imamate [leadership], happiness and guidance of mankind. He should also be the most knowledgeable of people in his era. Shiites do not believe in Imam's innate knowledge; rather they believe that the Imam's knowledge is acquired from holy Prophet (S) or other sources; therefore to ask prophet (PBUH & HF) a question is not counter to Imam's expansive knowledge.
There is also another possibility; The Imam (A.S) was trying to teach people that during holy Prophet's era (PBUH & HF) everyone should turn to him (the Prophet) not others so as to uphold his sacredness and scientific authority.
Detailed Answer
There is no disagreement among Muslim theologians that knowledge is necessary for the Imam. However, they have different views about the quantity and quality of his knowledge. Non-Shiite theologians consider ijtihadi (deductive) science [science obtained through effort and research] as sufficient which is subject to error. However, they do not consider it as necessary for the Imam to have a comprehensive knowledge of shari'a laws. Shiites on the contrary believe that Imam should have practical and comprehensive knowledge of shari'a laws; his knowledge should not be subject to error and he should be the most knowledgeable person of his time.
The scope of Imam's knowledge
There is not a consensus on Imam's knowledge among Shiite scholars. Nevertheless they are unanimous that Imam should know everything that is necessary for his imamate and mankind's happiness.
Ibn Meitham Bahrani, a Shiite theologian, says: "Imam should know everything required to perform his duties of imamate whether religious sciences or non-religious sciences; such as knowledge of shari'a laws, politics, manners, and settling disputes.[1]
Enumerating Imam's attributes, Muhaqqiq Tusi says: "The third attribute for Imam is his knowledge of every issue and all matters. That is to say, based on the judgment of the intellect, Imam should know everything about all his responsibilities of imamate; including knowledge of state affairs, political issues and what is expedient for people and what is not. He should also have knowledge of all the issues of shari'a and religion; because his ruling should comply with the injunctions of shari'a."[2]
Seyyed Mortaza, a great Shiite scholar, writes: "We seek refuge to God not to consider as necessary for Imam, sciences which are not related to his imamate and wilayat (guardianship)."[3]
Sources for Imam's knowledge
To find the answer to the present question, we must study the sources of Imam's knowledge and should find out as to where Imam's knowledge originate. Based on traditions narrated from holy Prophet and his household (S), the sources of Imam's knowledge are as follow:
1- Through the holy Prophet (S): Imam Ali (A.S) was brought up and reared at the Prophet's house. He was the holy Prophet's excellent disciple. Imam Ali (A.S) says: "The Messenger of Allah (S) taught me one thousand chapters (baab) of knowledge; each chapter consisted of yet another one thousand chapters."[4]
Someone asked Imam Sadiq (A.S) as to how he answered the questions. Imam Sadiq (A.S) said: "Any answer I give you is from holy Prophet (S)."[5]
2- Communication with angels: Communication with angels is not limited to the holy Prophet (S). The Quran says some individuals who were not prophet have communicated with angels such as Mary. One of the attributes mentioned for Imams in traditions is muhaddath, meaning that angels would speak with him.
Imam Sadiq (A.S) explains the meaning of muhaddath and says: "Imam hears the angel's sound but he does not see it."[6]
3- Special written sources which are accessible to Imams only; such as Lady Fatima's mus-haf (A.S) and Imam Ali's (A.S) Book.
4-Inspiration: Imam Baqir (A.S) says: "Imam Ali (A.S) would always act upon God's book and the holy Prophet's traditions (S) and whenever a new issue arose that was not mentioned in the Quran and tradition, God would inspire him with the truth."[7]
Imam Ali's (A.S) Knowledge
The fact that Imam Ali (A.S) is the most knowledgeable is crystal clear and confessed by everyone. Both Shiites and Sunnis have narrated that holy Prophet (S) has said: "I am the city of knowledge and Ali (A.S) is its gate".[8] Umar has said many times that "If it was not for Ali, Umar would have perished.[9]
Fakhr Razi, a great Sunni scholar, says about Imam Ali (A.S): "Ali (A.S) is pioneer in every science. Scholars in different fields of science are his students. In the field of Tafsir (exegesis) of the Quran, everyone was Abdullah bin Abbas' student and he was Imam Ali's (A.S) student. In the field of theology, there is no dispute that Imam Ali (A.S) initiated this science and that Ali (A.S) is the master of everyone in the world after holy Prophet (S)[10]. Therefore whatever has been narrated in Shiite and Sunni sources that Imam Ali (A.S) sent Meqdad to ask the holy Prophet (S) the ruling for mazi­ [11] is not in contrast to his expansive knowledge because, first, the holy Prophet (S) is one of the sources of Imam Ali's and other Imams' knowledge. Second, sending Meqdad to ask the holy Prophet (S) does not imply that Imam Ali (A.S) did not know the ruling; because there are other possibilities as well; for example by this act Imam Ali (A.S) would like everyone to know that his knowledge is from holy Prophet (S) and he did not say anything other than what he heard from Prophet (S).
There is another possibility here; Imam Ali (A.S) would try to teach people that during holy Prophet's time everyone should refer to him not others in order to maintain his sacredness and scientific authority.

[1]Bahrani, Meitham bin Ali, Qawa'ed al-Maram, p.179, second print, Al-Ketab publishing office, Bija, 1983
[2]Tousi, Muhammad bin Hassan, al-Eqtesad ela Tariq al-Reshad, p.192, printed by Chehel Sotoun Tehran Bookstore, Qom 1979
[3] Alam al-Hoda, Seyyed Morteza, al-Shafi fi al-Emama, vol.1, p.164, second print, al-Sadiq Institute, Tehran, 1989
[4] Razi, Muhammad bin Umar, al-Arba'een fi Usul al-Din, p.475, first print, Dar al-Ma'aref al-Uthmanyie, Haydarabad Dakan, 1934
[5]Kulayni, Muhammad bin Ya'qoob, Osool Kafi, vol.1, p.58, fourth print, Dar al-Kotob al-Eslamyie, Tehran,1986
[6] Osoole Kafi, vol.1, p.271
[7] Farrukh, Muhammad bin Hassan, Basa'er al-Darajat, p.235, Mar'ashi Najafi Library, Qom, 1404
[8] Hendi, Muttaqi, Kanz al-Ummal, vol.13, p.148, Mo'assesat al-Resala, Beirut, 1988; Soyuti, Jalal al-Din, al-Jame' al-Sagheer, vol.1, p.415, Dar al-Fekr, Beirut, 1981,; and other sources
[9] Amini, Muhammad Hussein, Al-Ghadir, vol.6, p.93, Darol Ketab al-Arabi, Beirut, Bita; Eejie, Al-Mawaqef, vol.3, p.627, first print, Dar al-Jeyl, Beirut, 1996; Ibn Abd al-Berr, al-Esti'ab, vol.3, p.1103, first print, Dar al-Jeyl, Beirut, 1991; and many other sources
[10] Al-Arba'een fi Osool al-Din, p.465
[11]  Mohaqqiq Hilli, al-Mo'tabar, vol.1, p.115, Seyyed al-Shohada Institute, Qom, 1985; Allamah Hilli, Tazkerat al-Fuqaha, vol.1, p.154, first print, Alul Bayt Institute, Qom, 1993; Ibn Hajar, Fat-h al-Bari, vol.1, p.325, second print, Dar al-Ma'refa, Beirut, (date not mentioned)
Question translations in other languages
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • Who are the infallibles (ma’sum)?
    7160 Traditional 2008/08/23
    Infallibility is a spiritual power and inner virtue that restrains one from even imagining and thinking of sinning, let alone committing sin and in Islamic terms, means for one to be protected from sin, mistake and forgetfulness.Infallibility can be divided into ...
  • If the imams are essentially infallible, can we follow them as role models?
    6178 عصمت 2015/05/03
    This question emanates from incorrect notion about the concept of infallibility that considers it something mandatory and gifted by God without a cause or reason. Obviously, if we are to consider infallibility as something forced, then we would consider the infallibles as people lacking free will and ...
  • Is it possible for a human to get married with a jinn?
    6817 Laws and Jurisprudence 2009/07/19
    Thank you for your question. First of all, it should be kept in mind that knowing the answer to such questions has no effect on our lives. There is no spiritual or material benefit for knowing these things. Secondly, although it is possible for ...
  • Why is a child that has been born from a temporary marriage given to the father?
    14701 Laws and Jurisprudence 2010/09/05
    Temporary marriage is an easy and simple marriage for people that can’t practice permanent marriage, legitimized by God for a number of reasons, one of which is to prevent fornication and sexual corruption. Consequently, God has excluded a few of the rulings and conditions required in permanent marriage ...
  • What is Shirk?
    34269 Traditional 2007/01/21
    Literally, shirk means to allocate; technically, in Quranic terminology, shirk – in contrast to hanif – signifies the process of allocating someone/thing as the Almighty Allah’s partner or equal. Hanif means being inclined towards righteousness and moderation; hence, the term has been coined onto those who have disassociated themselves from ...
  • What does Islam say about life on other planets?
    22054 Exegesis 2007/02/22
                Man has always pondered the thought of whether or not there are other living organisms or intelligent life forms in other galaxies or on other planets; however a definite answer has yet to be found.
  • What is Islam’s ruling on listening to music?
    13374 Laws and Jurisprudence 2010/11/21
    Music is essentially sound, and watching it (without listening) has no ruling; the only ruling there is, has to do with producing and the sale of instruments, teaching and learning, playing, and listening to it. Most scholars consider listening to and producing lahwi music to be haram and ...
  • How was the Holy Quran compiled?
    16168 Quranic Studies 2012/04/21
    According to the history of the compilation of the Quran, the Prophet (s) himself chose the verses where to be placed. It was not the companions who arranged the verses or the number of the chapters. The Quran, which is presently in our hands and which is ...
  • Who are the Ismaeili Bahreh Shias and what do they believe in?
    7591 تاريخ بزرگان 2010/04/19
    The "Bahreh Davoodis" are a branch of the "Ismaili" sect. The "Ismailis" believe Ismail, the son of Imam Jafar Sadiq (as) which passed away during his father's lifetime, to be the seventh Imam. The followers of this sect have unique beliefs that we will explain in the detailed ...
  • What are the effects of contentment on our lives and how do we distinguish it from stinginess?
    43285 Practical 2012/05/14
    Contentment has been defined as a resting of the mind without craving something else. The word “qana’ah” which is the Arabic equivalent for contentment has been used to refer to satisfaction and happiness in an absolute and unrestricted way. As for the difference between contentment and stinginess, ...