Visit
73117
Last Updated: 2012/02/18
Summary of question
Is lobster, clam, oyster and octopus halal?
question
Is lobster, clam, oyster and octopus halal? If so why is it sold in the Islamic Republic of Iran?
Concise answer

Eating lobster, clam, oyster and octopus is haram. According to religious resources regarding halal and haram meat, there are general rulings and numerous standards; for instance, a set of rulings has been given for land animals, sea creatures, birds and so on.

The condition for halal meat sea creatures is to have scales.

In a hadith from Imam Baqir (A.S.), Muhammad ibn Muslim asks: “We are given fish that do not bear an extra layer on them (scales)”. The Imam replied: “Eat all fish that have scales and do not eat those that do not.” [1] According to the ahadith, what is meant by the extra layer is the scales. [2]

The Great Maraje’ Taqlid have pointed out the ruling of sea creatures based on these traditions.

They state that based on the ahadith, every sea creature is haram except those that have scales. However, shrimp is an exception to this general ruling. We have a special hadith that considers shrimp as an exception: “Eating it (shrimp) is permissible, for it is a kind of fish”. [3]

Despite the fact that, essentially shrimp don’t have scales, from the legal perspective it is set within the category of fish that have scales. In other words, for reasons we are not aware of, it has been considered as an exception and consequently halal, although it doesn’t have scales. [4]

In addition, we have a hadith that states the impermissibility of crab:

“Eating jer ī (type of fish), turtle and crab is haram.” [5]

Therefore, octopus, etc. remain within the general ruling of impermissibility.

One must note that being legally inedible does not make it haram to sell, purchase or catch, because the prohibition of eating something is a complete different thing from the prohibition of selling and purchasing it the same thing. There are cases where a certain thing is haram to eat or drink but can be sold and purchased. For example, blood. It is haram to eat but can be purchased and sold for other benefits. Therefore, purchasing and selling lobster, clam, oyster, etc. in the market, for reasons other than eating like benefiting from the other uses it has, is permissible. Perhaps lobster, clam, etc. have other benefits as well.

For more information please refer to question 492(533).



[1] Sheikh Hurr Ameli, Wasa’il al-Shia, vol. 16, pp. 397 and 398, hadith 1 of chapter 8, the chapters on foods and drinks.

[2] Ibid, hadiths 3 and 7.

[3] Wasa’il al-Shia ,pg. 408, hadiths 5 and 12, book of foods and drinks.

[4] Footnote of Wasa’il al-Shia, pg. 408.

[5] Wasa’il al-Shia , vol. 24, pg. 146, book of foods and drinks, chapter 16, hadith 1.

Detailed Answer
This question does not have a detailed answer.
Question translations in other languages
Comments
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • When and by whom did idol worshipping start in Mecca?
    21107 تاريخ بزرگان 2012/02/15
    After the tribe of Khuza’ah gained authority of the Kabah, the first person in charge was Amr ibn Lahiyy. His name was Harith ibn Amir. Amir changed the religion of Ibrahim (A.S.) and prompted people to worship statues. According to a narration, he went to Syria and witnessed a ...
  • If prayer is the pillar of faith, why is it considered to be part of the branches of religion?
    771 نماز 2017/01/21
    The fundaments of faith or principles of religion are the religious tenets which man believes in with his own insight and understanding without relying on others. It is only after believing in those fundamentals of faith that he becomes Muslim and should start fulfilling individual and social ...
  • What is khums and what is it paid on?
    4283 آنچه خمس بدان تعلق می گیرد 2012/12/16
    Khums literally means “one-fifth or 20%”. In Islamic legal terminology, it means “one-fifth of certain items which a person earns by means of trade, industry, agricultural work, research or any other ways of earning, like, if he earns some money by working in a government department, and ...
  • Shias believe that the majority of the Sahabah were infidels and hypocrites, if so than why didn't they just kill the minority of true believers?
    5326 Traditional 2009/09/01
    What Shias believe regarding the Sahabah is not the abovementioned belief. Shias believe that some of the Sahabah didn't act according to some teachings of Islam after he passed away and that there were times that they altered some teachings and most of them put aside what they ...
  • Is it bad to be alone in a room with a non mahram girl?
    3716 Practical 2012/03/10
    In religious teachings, one of the things man has been advised against in order to protect him from sin, is to be alone with a non-mahram. In his advice to Prophet Musa (AS), Satan says: “O Musa, never be alone with a non-mahram woman, for ...
  • Is it haram to get a tattoo?
    5458 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/12/01
    The answer given by Ayatollah Mahdi Hadavi Tehrani (may Allah grant him long life) is as under:If it is not harmful to your body and the tattoo shapes are not offensive and do not in any way degrade your personality, there is no objection.
  • What are the origin and beliefs of Ya'furiyah sect?
    3423 تاريخ کلام 2011/10/30
    There is not much information about Ya'furiyah in history. What has been mentioned in historical resources is the following: 1. Ya'furiyah sect refers to the followers of Muhammad bin Bashir who ceased to believe in the Imamate (leadership) of Musa bin Ja'far and later denied ...
  • What reason do Shia scholars have that proves the story of “Abdullah bin Saba’” by ‘Seyf bin Umar’ to be forged and false?
    5772 تاريخ بزرگان 2011/05/22
    The true Islam is that which the Shia follow, the teachings of which Imam Ali (as) has received from the prophet and transmitted to his followers. The attribution of Shia beliefs to a Jew by the name of Abdullah bin Saba’, as many intellectual and narrative reasons affirm, ...
  • I lack spiritual presence in my prayers, what should I do to change this?
    3970 Practical 2010/04/20
    Prayer consists of physical and spiritual aspects. Like the physical aspect, the spiritual aspect is also characterized by a series of conditions and disciplines.Therefore, in the same way certain conditions define the proper physical aspect of prayer (such as purity of one’s clothes, facing qiblah, and being ...
  • Is it permissible for a woman to dance in a wedding?
    3667 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/10/04
    There is no doubt that it is forbidden for a woman to dance for men.[1] As for a woman's dancing for women in parties or weddings which are not likely to be frequented by men, the opinions of the grand jurists are as ...

Popular