Advanced search
Last Updated: 2014/12/10
Summary of question
What was Imam Sadiq (AS)'s argument about God's existence in his debate with Abu Shaker Daysani?
Assalam-alaikum, In the book, "The great Muslim scientist and philosopher", there is a discussion between Imam Jaffer As-Sadiq A.S. and an atheist 'Abu shakir'. During the discussion some deep scientific knowledge is revealed. Now some people have said that the entire book is fake. Can you please inform if one can locate the discussion between the Imam A.S. and the atheist named Abu Shakir, specifically, in any of the hadith books?
Concise answer
During the lifetime of Imam Ja'far Sadiq (AS), theological debates and discussions invovling the Imam himself were carried out quite often. One of the most serious topics around which discussions and debates took place was the existence of God. Due, mainly, to the free atmosphere prevailing in Arabia, the discussions would often take place among members of the opposite groups. There is no doubt that these discussions ultimately ended up in the victory of the theists ands monotheists and the defeat of the disbelievers. One of those who had lengthy debates with Imam Ja'far Sadiq, peace be upon him, was Abu Shakir Daysani.[i] What follows is a report on two dialogues between him and Imam Ja'far Sadiq (AS) regarding the existence of God, the Exalted:
1. Hesham bin Hakam narrates:
Abu Shakir told me that he had a question and he asked me to arrange a meeting with my teacher, Imam Ja'far Sadiq (AS) because he had a question which he had asked many scholars but he had not got a convincing answer.
Hesham asked Abu Shakir if he did not want  him to know about his question. He said that might perhaps have an answer to his question which he might probably like but Abu Shakir insisted that he wanted to meet Imam Sadiq (AS) and ask him his question as well.
Hesham says that he arranged a meeting for him and he asked his question:
Abu Shakir said to the Imam (AS): “Would you allow me to say something and ask some questions?"
Imam Sadiq (AS) said: "What is your question?"
Abu Shakir al-Daysani asked Imam al-Sadiq (AS): "How can you prove that you have a Creator?"
Consequently, he (AS) responded: "I found myself not free from one of the two possibilities: either I have created myself, or someone else has created me. If I have created myself, then I am not free from one of two meanings: either I created myself while I was already existent, or I created myself while I was nonexistent. Hence, if I created myself, and I already existed, then I was self-sufficient of giving existence to myself. And if I was nonexistent, then you know that the nonexistent cannot bring about a thing. Therefore, the third meaning is proven that I have a Creator and that is Allah, the Lord of the Universe."[ii]
2. One day Abu Shakir came to the Imam and said, “Prove to me the existence of God.” Imam (a.s) told him to be seated. At that time a boy passed by holding a hen’s egg. Imam (a.s) called him, and taking the egg from him kept it on his palm. Then he told Abu Shakir, “See, it is such a strong fort that has no doors. On its outside is a hard skin and below it is a thin membrane, inside which flow two seas of gold and silver. But neither can the yellow mix with the white nor the white can merge with the yellow. Neither can a repairer enter it nor a destroyer comes out of it. No one can even know whether the newborn would be a male or a female. Then all of a sudden it cracks and a beautiful chick emerges from it. Can your reason agree that all this happened without a designer or a maker?” Hearing this Abu Shakir bowed down his head and said, “I repent for my beliefs today and accept the religion of Islam.”[iii]
Although these two reports do not have so strong chain of narration, their contents are coherent and consistent with the fundamentals of Islamic beliefs and theology. Thus, they can be used to argue with. Indeed, the argument in the second narration somehow signifies the kind of knowledge which Daysani had no knowledge before it.

[i] Vide: Kulayni, Muhammad bin Ya'qub, Al-Kafi, researched and corrected by Ghaffari, Ali Akbar, Akhundi, Muhammad, vol.1, p. 128, Dar al-Kotob al-Islamiyah, fourth edition, 1407 A.H; Ibn Shahr Ashub Mazandarani, Muhammad bin Ali, Mutashabeh al-Qur'an wa Mukhtalifehi, vol.1, p. 48, Qom, Beidar, first edition, 1410 A.H.
[ii] Sheiky Saduq, Al-Tawhid, researched and corrected by Husseini, Hashem, p. 290, Qom, Islamic Publications Office, first edition, 1398 A.H.
[iii] Al-Kafi, vol.1, p, 80; Tabarsi, Ahmad bin Ali, Al-Ehtijaj 'Alaa al-Lejaj, researched and corrected by Khursan, Muhammad Baqir, vol.2, p. 333, Mashad, Murteza Publication, first edition, 1403 A.H.
Question translations in other languages
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • Has Islam reffered to any special form of government?
    7185 Fiqh 2006/08/21
    It should be said that Islam hasn,t reffered to any special form of government has expressed certain rules and regulation in this connection, form which the method of Islamic government can be inferred. Who infers these rules? The abovementioned rules are: finality of the fatva (verdict) of the specialist in ...
  • Whose saying is this: "Death is sweater to me than honey."
    6952 تاريخ بزرگان 2011/01/10
    This saying is widely ascribed to Qasim son of Imam Hasan Mujtaba (a.s.). It is said that when his beloved uncle, Imam Hussein (a.s.) asked him "My child, my nephew, tell me, how do you regard death and what do you think about getting killed?" He promptly answered: ...
  • Is it lawful to get a marital judgment from a non-Muslim government?
    6182 Laws and Jurisprudence 2007/01/07
    Referring to judicial arbitrators in non-Muslim and oppressive governments, and requesting their help is not permissible, save in cases where attaining one's right is dependent upon it, and there is no other way. And it is obvious that taking ...
  • Is it possible for humankind to know Allah (awj)? If yes, to what degree and what is the value of such knowledge?
    10074 Traditional 2011/08/15
    The human being can attain knowledge of Allah (awj) through various ways. This knowledge can come about through the medium of the intellect or of the heart. At times he—as in the case of the sage and the philosopher—reasons and understands through conceptual knowledge ...
  • Is it haraam (impermissible) to celebrate birthdays within Islam?
    15484 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/01/12
    Celebrating birthdays is not a part of the Islamic traditions; it is a matter about which the Shari`ah is silent. The Islamic doctrines have not persuaded or recommended us to celebrate our birthdays. However, we do not want to condemn this new tradition, even though we do not accept ...
  • What is the Sunni viewpoint regarding the Mus’haf of Imam Ali (as)?
    15698 Contextual study 2010/04/06
    What is meant by the Mus’haf of Imam Ali (as) is the Quran in which he compiled after the passing of the prophet (pbuh). In this Quran things like the exact order of the verses and surahs according to the time of their revelation have ...
  • Why is full hijab compulsory for Muslim women in Iran?
    7488 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/12/11
    Hijab is one of the Islamic duties which existed in other religions also. It has been stated in the Holy Quran and in numerous traditions that a woman should cover all parts of her body except her face and hands up to the wrists. Therefore, the ...
  • If the horn of a sacrificial animal is broken, can we sacrifice it on Eid al-Adha?
    5997 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/02/14
    If what you mean by sacrifice, is the sacrifice performed as one of the rituals of Hajj where animals are sacrificed in the land of Mina, then according to the fatwa of the majority of jurists, if the animal originally had a horn in its creation (even if ...
  • What legal reference do we have for Eid Nowruz?
    23314 Contextual study 2011/05/22
    This eid is an ancient Persian holiday that was marked and celebrated before the emergence of Islam.There is a hadith from Imam Sadeq (as) in hadith sources regarding Nowruz which the popular vote has verified it to be reliable and therefore they have given the fatwa to the ...
  • What is the ruling on having a sexual relationship with one of the Maharem?
    14443 Laws and Jurisprudence 2010/12/21
    This question doesn’t have a brief answer. Please click on the detailed answer. ...