Advanced search
Visit
8294
Last Updated: 2012/02/15
Summary of question
Why do Shīʿas say ‘Alḥamdulillāh rabbi al-ʿālamīn' after sūrah ‘al-Hamd’.
question
Why do Shīʿas say ‘Alḥamdulillāh rabbi al-ʿālamīn’ after surah ‘al-Hamd’? What is the philosophy behind this? And why do the Shīʿah believe that saying ‘Ameen’ in its place (after sūrah ‘al-Hamd’) invalidates the prayer?
Concise answer

There are some apparent differences which exist, and have existed between Shīʿas and Sunnis; for instance, the folding of arms during prayer as practiced by the Sunnis, or the method in which ‘wuḍhu’ is performed can be cited as examples of apparent differences (in the form of practices) in Jurisprudence between the two schools. The causes for these differences are actually rooted in more fundamental issues, which have been discussed in detail elsewhere on this site.

As to why Shīʿas recite ‘Alḥamdulillāh rabbi al-ʿālamīn’ instead of ‘Ameen’ after sūrah ‘al-Hamd’:

Prayer is amongst the acts of worship in which the contents (of prayer) are determined by the Holy Qur'ān and traditions from the Holy Prophet (pbuh) and his household (they are not derived through rational). In prayer, one must not recite anything other than ‘ḏikr’; otherwise the prayer would become void. Just as the Shīʿah have obtained all the rest of their teachings through the instructions and commandments of the Prophet and his household (pbut), in this matter too they act in accordance to their instructions. Based upon narrations, the Ahlulbayt have told us that ‘saying ‘Ameen’ after reciting sūrah ‘al-Hamd’ is not part of the prayer, hence it is not permissible to say it’. It is narrated from Imam Sadiq (pbuh): ‘Whenever you are praying in congregation, and the leader of the congregation finishes reciting ‘Al-Hamd’, do not say ‘Ameen’, say instead ‘Alḥamdulillāh rabbi al-ʿālamīn’.[1]

The maraji’ have given the following fatwa based on the mentioned narration: ‘Of the acts which invalidate the prayer; is saying ‘Ameen’ after reciting ‘al-Hamd’, although if someone says it mistakenly or out of ‘taqīyah’ (dissimulation), the prayer is not void’.[2]

Finally, it is necessary to mention that according to Shīʿah Islamic law, it is not actually compulsory to say ‘Alḥamdulillāh rabbi al-ʿālamīn’ after ‘al-Hamd’; it is just mustahabb (preferable)[3]. However, most Sunni schools of thought consider it an obligatory part of prayer[4], hence the onus is upon them to verify their claim through the Qur'ān and Prophetic Traditions.



[1] Tusi, Muhammad bin al-Hasan, al-Tahdhib, vol. 2, pg. 74.

[2] Tawdih al-Masa’il (annotated by Imam Khomeini), vol. 1, pg. 617. This ruling is agreed upon by all the respected jurists.

[3] Ibid, pg. 559.

[4] Of course, according to the explicit mention of great Sunni figures and commentators of the Quran, saying ‘Ameen’ is not part of the prayer. (Muhammad Rashid Ridha, al-Minar, vol. 1, pg. 39)

Detailed Answer
This question does not have a detailed answer.
Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • Is it possible to say that since the ayah of taṭhīr is located in the middle of the ayah, it does not entail exclusivity? Who are the Ahl al-Bayt?
    7675 Exegesis 2012/05/21
    In response to the first section of the question, the ayah of taṭhīr is located in the middle of another larger ayah, but the most this issue can imply is that it is out of context when considering the preceding and following section of the ayah and ...
  • The Quran is the last Book revealed by Allah Almighty. What are the reasons to prove that the Quran is a miracle?
    16760 Quranic Studies 2012/04/11
    Different explanations have been given about the Quran being a miracle which can be sorted out under the following three categories: miracle in terms of the words of the Quran, miracle in terms of the contents and miracle in terms of its bringer. 1. The ...
  • Why was Hazrat Muhammad (P.B.U.H.) allowed to have more than four wives?
    17002 Philosophy of Religion and Law 2007/04/05
    The topic of the prophet of Islam’s (P.B.U.H.) marriages and number of spouses is a subject which has been questioned very much. In reference to this issue, we should mention first of all that before the ruling for the impermissibility of ...
  • How can a person be forgiven for his sins?
    9156 Practical 2010/12/21
    There are many ways mentioned below that one can be forgiven and purified from his sins and misdeeds:1- Repenting according to its conditions and returning to Allah. 2- Doing extraordinary good deeds that cause the ...
  • What does Shia doctrine say about the awaited Mahdi?
    10963 Traditional 2012/01/17
    Since the above question is too vague and general, we decided to have a brief introduction of Imam’s (AJ) lifestyle, assertions from the unseen (akhbar ghaibi) and signs of his reappearance.His name is the same as the prophet of Islam’s, and ...
  • What is the ruling on shaving the beard and body hair?
    18342 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/01/17
    Only shaving or trimming facial hair (beard)[1] with shaving machines in a way that people say there is no beard anymore, is impermissible based on obligatory precaution.[2] Also, shaving a portion of the beard has the same ruling as ...
  • Do Shiites differentiate between Allah and Imams?
    7542 Traditional 2012/10/11
    Like all other schools, Shiite school has been encountering extremist groups that are called by different names such as ghulāt (exaggerators), muqassera and nawasib and which have, in the course of history, created difficulties for Shiites and their Imams. Shiite Imams made continuous efforts to protect Shiites ...
  • If a non-Muslim gives us salaams saying “Assalaamu Alaykum”, how should we respond?
    7951 Theoretical 2012/04/17
    One of the issues that has been emphasized in our religious teachings is greeting other believers with salams. There are exceptions to this teaching though, greeting non-Muslims being one of them. In jurisprudential books, greeting non-Muslims has been deemed as makruh: "When responding to the greetings of a ...
  • What were the main causes of the crusades?
    33922 History 2015/08/04
    The Crusades were a series of military attacks launched by Western Europe on Muslims and the Islamic world from 1095 to 1291. These wars which were sanctioned by Christian leadership and the Catholic Church, took place between followers of two big and powerful religions in a very ...
  • What is the best name one can pick for their child?
    7817 Contextual study 2011/04/21
    Names portray the owner of the name and whenever a name is said, the owner immediately comes to mind, therefore it is important to choose suitable and good names. It has been mentioned in ahadith that the best and most suitable name is one that denotes obedience; the ...

Popular