Advanced search
Last Updated: 2013/12/05
Summary of question
Is Hazrat Ali Asgar (AS) buried on the chest of Imam Hossein (AS) in the same grave?
Is Hazrat Ali Asgar (AS) buried on the chest of Imam Hossein (AS) in the same grave?
Concise answer
In this regard, Martyr Qadhi Tabatabai (ra) says in the footnote of his book titled "An Investigation into the First Arba'ein of Imam Hussein (a.s)" as such: "This story is heard on the tongues of some people especially those who give lectures on the pulpits that when Imam Sajjad (a.s.) wanted to bury Ali Asghar  (a.s.), he placed him on the chest of the Chief of Martyrs, Imam Hussein (a.s). This allegation is unsubstantiated and has no proper chain of transmission.  In addition, this is problematic and objectionable according to jurisprudential law as well, because it has been stated in the etiquettes concerning the burial of a deceased person that the corpse should be laid on its right side so that the dead body's face is in the direction of Qibla. He should not be laid in the grave with his chest towards the sky and toes towards the Qibla. If it had been allowed as such, it could be assumed that Ali Asghar's body was placed on the Imam's chest. Of course, it can be said that Imam Sajjad, peace be upon him, may have buried Ali Asghar opposite to Imam Hussein's chest with his face towards the Qibla. Such an assumption is allowed and supposable but there is no narration or proof to substantiate this point either. Perhaps, the reporter may have meant that Ali Asghar's martyrdom was so difficult and unbearable for Imam Hussein, peace be upon him, that the incident burnt his holy heart. It was as though Ali Asghar was buried on his father's chest. Such an interpretation is figurative and has nothing to do with the concrete action. Hence, the famous saying is that which has been said by historiographers that:  "The martyrs of Karbala including Ali Asghar (a.s.) are buried beneath Imam Hussein's feet.[1]

[1] Qadhi Tabatabai, Sayed Muhammad Ali, "An Investigation into the First Arba'ein of Imam Hussein (a.s.), p. 95, Ministry of Guidance, Tehran, 1383 (2004).
Question translations in other languages
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • Do all of the prophet’s (pbuh) words and sayings come from revelation?
    4879 Traditional
    The experts have different viewpoints on this issue:Taking into consideration verses 3 and 4 of surah Najm[i], some believe that all of the prophet’s sayings and actions originate from revelation.Others believe that verse 4 of this surah has to do with Quranic verses ...
  • When Maghrib and Isha prayer become Qaza?
    26437 زمان
    The answer given to the question by the office of Grand Ayatollah Khamenei is as follow: The last time for performing Maghrib and Isha prayer is at canonical midnight. (i.e: 11 ¼ hours after, the canonical noon). The precaution states that if one hasn’t performed one’s salat ...
  • Please count four of the Prophet’s miracles that have been mentioned in the Quran.
    7264 Exegesis
    An act that prophets do to prove their prophethood that normal individuals aren’t capable of doing is called a “miracle”.The Holy Quran is the greatest miracle of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). In the Quran, there are numerous verses that speak of and prove it being a miracle. In addition ...
  • What is the best verse in the Quran?
    5345 Exegesis
    Before dealing with the main question, we must say that the Quran itself is the best book and superior to all heavenly books. All of its verses (ayāt) are at the highest level of perfection and significance. Hence, we cannot differentiate between them by telling that a ...
  • How can one prevent and free oneself from loving other than Allah (swt) excessively?
    4341 Practical
    The human being is a social creature and in need of connecting with others in order to survive. Nevertheless, he should secure his prosperity and salvation in this world and the next by selecting a worthy friend and keeping the friendship moderate, away from all ...
  • What is the starting point for purifying the soul?
    5385 Practical
    Purification means to clean your soul of impurity. The Quran has mentioned purifying the soul in various verses but one should know that the basis and starting point of purification varies from person to person.  For a person that is not Muslim, the first essential step will be ...
  • Why didn’t Imam Ali (AS) punish the murderers of Uthman?
    1831 امام علی ع و خلفا
    1. Uthman was not killed by only one individual so that he could be brought to book; rather an extensive uprising was launched an angry mob against him. The uprising led ultimately to his death. Imam Ali (AS) could not punish thousands of people for launching an ...
  • By which reason we must recite "اعوذ بالله من الشیطان الرجیم" before "بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم"?
    7590 ابلیس و شیطان
    Since "بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم" is the part (verse) of the Holy Quran, saying "اعوذ بالله من الشیطان الرجیم" before it, is one of the rules in regards to recite the Holy Quran that is mentioned in the Holy Quran itself and traditions. However, taking ...
  • rules and regulations has Islam prescribed for exultations and happiness?
    3588 Practical
    Real happiness from the perspective of a faithful individual is achieved when he performs an act which draws him one step closer to his Lord. However, human beings can benefit from lawful and diverse worldly pleasures so as to satiate his natural desire. At times, these actions ...
  • Please explain the meanings of the names and attributes of Allah (swt).
    3916 Theoretical
    The Holy Quran says: “The most beautiful names belong to Allah: So call on Him by them”[1] There are many names for Allah (swt) and most of them are mentioned in the dua of Jawshan Kabir. Each of these names points to one ...