Advanced search
Visit
10067
Last Updated: 2012/01/30
Summary of question
If Aisha was the Mother of the Faithful and the Quran has described her as being "pure", then why did she go into a war with Imam Ali (a.s)?
question
If Aisha was the Mother of the Faithful and the Quran has described her as being "pure", then why did she go into a war with Imam Ali (a.s)? Did Imam Ali (a.s.) err or God?
Concise answer

If you mean by the word "pure" absolute and comprehensive purity which is what Ayah of Tathir (purification) refers to, then it relates only to the Holy Prophet (s), Imam Ali (a.s), Fatima (s.a), Imam Hasan (a.s.) and Imam Hussain (a.s.); it does not include the wives of the Holy Prophet (s). However, being pure from charges of indecency (the story of the Ifk) does not imply their inerrancy in their political and social activities. The Holy Quran denounces and threatens to divorce some of the wives of the Prophet (s) because of their misdemeanors and exposing of his secrets.

Detailed Answer

There are a few points that need to be explained in connection with the above question:

1. The meaning of the Prophet's wives being the mothers of the believers: In verse 6 of Sura al-Ahzab, God, the Exalted, addresses the believers as such: "The Prophet is closer to the Believers than their own selves, and his wives are their mothers…"[1] This verse seeks to explain the prohibition of the believers' marriage with the wives of the Holy Prophet (s). Else where the Quran says: "And it is not right for you that you should give trouble to the Messenger of Allah, nor that you should marry his wives after him ever; surely this is grievous in the sight of Allah."[2] This verse does not denote anything more than this.[3]

2. Declaration of the purity of the wives of the Prophet (s) in the Quran: If you mean by the word "pure" in your question absolute and comprehensive purity which is what Ayah of Tathir (purification) refers to, then it relates only to the Holy Prophet (s), Imam Ali (a.s), Fatima (s.a), Imam Hasan (a.s.) and Imam Hussain (a.s.); it does not include the wives of the Holy Prophet (s).

For further information in this regard, refer to Index: Ayah of Tathir (Purification), question 1504 (site: 1557).

As for being pure from charges of indecency, the story of the Ifk (slander) relates to one of the battles of the Prophet (s). According to some reports narrated by Sunni narrators, one of the wives of the Prophet (Aisha or Mariyah Qibtiyah)[4] was also present in the battle. For some reasons, she had fallen behind the caravan. Unfortunately, some hypocrites who had seen the Prophet's wife (in a lonely condition with another man) began to gossip and spread slanderous lies about her. Eventually the story reached the Prophet himself and by then the whole community was talking about what might or might not have happened to her. God rejected this accusation in order to defend the Prophet stressing on the purity of the Prophet's wife from accusation.[5] In the foregoing verse, the Quran stresses on the purity of the Prophet's wives from indecent actions.  This statement is not only defending the purity of the wives of the Prophet (s) but it is also defending the Holy Prophet's honor and respect because such a false accusation deters the prophethood. However, this confession on the part of the Quran does not mean that the Prophet's wives are immune to all kinds of mistakes and errors. They are not infallible in the same way as the Prophet (s) or the Imams because the Quran asks two of the Holy Prophet's wives who had committed mistakes and who had exposed some of the secrets of the Prophet (s) to repent. It says:

"If ye two turn in repentance to Him, your hearts are indeed so inclined; But if ye back up each other against him, truly Allah is his Protector, and Gabriel, and (every) righteous one among those who believe,- and furthermore, the angels - will back (him) up. It may be, if he divorced you (all), that Allah will give him in exchange consorts better than you,- who submit (their wills), who believe, who are devout, who turn to Allah in repentance, who worship (in humility), who travel (for Faith) and fast,- previously married or virgins."[6] 

According to all tafasir (commentary books) of both Sunnis and Shi'ah, these two women (the revealers of the secrets) were Hafsah and Aishah.[7]

These verses clearly speak about these two women opposing the command of the Prophet and about God threatening them to divorce by the Prophet (s). The question is: Given that these two women opposed the Prophet (s) and did what they should not have done, was it not possible that they commit mistakes even after the demise of the Prophet (s)? Is their opposition to Imamate and Wilayah stranger or more weird than their opposition to the Prophet (s)? There is no doubt that all Muslim religions agree that following Uthman's assassination, Imam Ali (a.s) had definitely been the fourth caliph and successor to the Prophet (s). It had been obligatory on all Muslims to obey him. Certainly opposing him and revolting against him amount to opposing and revolting against the Prophet (s). In addition, the Prophet's wives have been commanded in the Quran to stay indoors and to guard themselves against evils[8], are their revolt and participation in a battle against the guardian of the affairs of Muslims in compliances with the Quranic verse?!!

You can study the reasons behind the Battle of Camel (Jamal) by referring to question 158 (site: 1250).



[1] - Al-Ahzab, 6

[2] - Al-Ahzab, 53

[3] - There are many Sunni exegetes who believe that the title Ummul Momeneen (the Mother of Faithful) makes reference to the prohibition of marriage with the wives of the Prophet (s) and to their dignity and respect.

[4] - Tafsir Qommi, vol.2, pg. 99.

[5] - Al-Noor, 11.

[6] - Al-Tahrim, 4 & 5

[7] - Tabatabai, Muhammad Hussein, Translation of Al-Mizan, vol.19, pg. 555, Jame'ah Mudarresin of the Islamic Seminary of Qom, Qom, 1374 (1995); Fath al-Qadir, vol.5, pg. 298; Anwar al-Tanzil, vo.5, pg. 224, Al-Bahr al-Mohit fi al-Tafsir, vol.10, pg. 210.

[8] - Al-Ahzab, 33.

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • Is it true that some Muslim Gnostics can fly or levitate?
    12266 Practical 2007/02/08
    That which you have mentioned is an effect and result of Man’s spiritual strength, sometimes this may come about by acting in accordance with religious laws and legitimate ascetic discipline. This means that; by moving closer to Allah, Man can possess the greatest name ...
  • What are the distinct criteria through which we can distinguish a lafdhi mutawatir report from an ijmali or ma\'anawi one?
    9619 Contextual study 2014/09/28
    Mutawatir literally means for things to come one after another, without any interval between them and in hadithic terms, refers to a hadith that has been narrated by a group of narrators that one can be definite haven’t all agreed on forging and lying about altogether. Any ...
  • What are the features and privileges of Behar al-Anwar?
    6998 Contextual study 2015/05/03
    Behar al-Anwa being a huge hadith collection is the most important work by Allamah Muhammad Baqir Majlisi. It is a big encyclopedia of Shiite traditions encompassing all religious issues and themes including exegesis of the Quran, history, jurisprudence, theology etc. Some of the most important features of ...
  • Please explain the principles of Sheikh Toosi's political thought.
    8594 Laws and Jurisprudence 2010/12/21
     With the emergence of every era new needs and questions are generated which cause scientists and scholars to think and contemplate and strive to find appropriate answers to, and Sheikh Toosi is one the great scholars who has carried such a burden. The fundamentals of ...
  • Are there any women who reached the rank of ijtihad in religious seminaries?
    9574 تاريخ بزرگان 2007/11/04
    A worthy interaction of Islam with science, and requiring that from every Muslim man and woman, has resulted in women always studying the sciences in Islamic communities and finally some of them reached the rank of ijtihad.As an example, lady Mujtahideh Amin who passed away in 1403h. Lady Mujtahideh ...
  • Who were the Ansar?
    9406 تاريخ بزرگان 2010/04/07
    Ansar is the plural form of Naser from the root of Nasr, and means people who help and aid. In the advent of Islam, the residents of Medinah and its outskirts, especially the members of the two tribes of the Aws and Khazraj were called the Ansar, because ...
  • What is the relationship between man’s efforts and the sustenance that has been measured out for him?
    12817 Traditional 2011/08/15
    There are two kinds of sustenance. There is a sustenance that we go after and a sustenance that comes after us. In the traditions, the sustenance that comes after us is called “the sustenance that seeks,” and the sustenance that we seek has been named “the sought ...
  • What is the proof for Prophet Adam and Nuh (pbuh) being buried in Najaf?
    23457 تاريخ بزرگان 2010/07/20
    The main reasoning that proves the burial of Prophet Adam and Nuh (pbuh) in Najaf are the many hadith that disclose this fact. ...
  • Is it permissible to evade government tax in non-Islamic countries?
    7801 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/01/10
    The answer given by Ayatollah Mahdi Hadavi Tehrani is as follows:1. You must abide by the rules of the country in which you are living except for when the rules may be opposed to Islamic Shari'ah.
  • I wish to know what the seven paradises are. Can you explain them for me?
    47501 Traditional 2012/04/07
    Dar al-Salam (Abode of Peace), Dar al-Jalal (Abode of Glory), Jannatul Mava (Garden of Refuge), Jannatul Khuld (Garden of Eternity), Jannatul Adan (Garden of Eden), Jannatul Firdous (Garden of Paradise) and Jannatul Naeem (Garden of Bliss) (or Delight) are names for the seven paradises which have been ...

Popular