Advanced search
Last Updated: 2009/08/11
Summary of question
Which people is the hadith that says during the return of Imam Mahdi (aj) some will lose their faiths and others who are kafir will embrace faith, speaking of?
There is a hadith in Mizanul-Hikmah about Imam Zaman that says: “Some who worship the sun and stars will join the ranks of Imam Mahdi (aj) when he comes, and some who claim to be his followers and supporters will desert him.” Please explain this hadith and to whom it is referring to.
Concise answer

This question doesn’t have a brief answer. Please click on the detailed answer.

Detailed Answer

Mizanul-Hikmah has narrated this hadith from the book Al-Gheybah of Nu’mani. Nu’mani narrates Ibrahim ibn Abdil-Hamid saying (regarding the Shias at the time of the emergence of the Mahdi (aj)): “One who had heard from Imam Sadiq (as) told me: “When the Qa’im (the standing/waiting one, Imam Mahdi (as)) emerges, one who used to think he was a follower of the imam (as) will disobey him and some like those who worship the sun and stars will accept the imam’s wilayah and authority [and join him].”[1]

Although the narrators of this hadith are reliable, it is a mursalah hadith, because Ibrahim ibn Abdil-Hamid who is a companion of Imam Kadhim (as) says that ‘someone’ who had heard Imam Sadiq (as) told him, without specifying who the ‘someone’ is. Thus, this hadith is a mursalah one, making it unreliable.

As for the message of the hadith, it is saying that at the imam’s (as) time, some who thought they were true followers of the imam (as) will deny his leadership (as a result of not bearing the capacity for such) and authority. But on the other hand, a group of disbelievers whom the hadith refers to as “people like those who worship the sun and the stars” (meaning that they are mushriks) will grasp the truth and join the ranks of the imam (as) and aid him.

Therefore, this hadith is apparently speaking of those who claim to have faith and have accepted the authority and leadership of the imam (as), but when the time for action comes, they fail the test and disobey him; not only do they not reach salvation with the imam’s (as) emergence, but also join the wrong side and fight against him and end in total loss. Meanwhile, some who are on the wrong paths of shirk and kufr and fed up with all the oppression and injustice in the world will find faith in the imam (as) and accept his leadership when they see his just government.

Of course, Allamah Majlisi has narrated this same hadith with the same chain of narrators slightly different:

“When the Qa’em emerges, those who thought they were the followers of the imam will stray from this path and will become of those who worship the sun and moon (will become mushriks).”[2]

Meaning that those who didn’t have true faith will not only desert the imam (as), but will turn away from Islam and join the ranks of the mushriks and enemies of Islam and the imam (as).

What this hadith is actually doing is point to the many hardships during the time of the imam’s (as) return, and that if one isn't ‘armed’ and ready with taqwa and piety and hasn’t taken refuge in true faith and good deeds, he well stray from the straight path.

[1] Nu’mani, Al-Gheybah, pg. 317; ReyShahri, Mizanul-Hikmah, vol. 1, pg. 187; “حدثنا أحمد بن محمد بن سعید ابن عقدة قال حدثنا حمید بن زیاد عن علی بن الصباح قال حدثنا أبو علی الحسن بن محمد الحضرمی قال حدثنی جعفر بن محمد عن إبراهیم بن عبد الحمید قال أخبرنی من سمع أبا عبد الله ع یقول:" إذا خرج القائم ع خرج من هذا الأمر من کان یرى أنه من أهله و دخل فیه شبه عبدة الشمس و القمر

[2] Majlisi, Biharul-Anwar, vol. 52, pg. 364.

Question translations in other languages
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • What is the meaning of being infallible?
    9197 Traditional 2008/05/11
    Allamah Tabatabai states: "Infallibility" means the presence of a quality in the infallible person that protects him or her from doing what is not permissible (e.g. sin or error)".[1] It should be noted that from his viewpoint God's prophets (and all of the ...
  • Please explain the basis of Shi'ite thought and its characteristics?
    7621 Traditional 2010/09/18
    The Holy Quran is the basis of the Shi'ite thought and the source of all the Shiite teachings. It considers the apparent and outward meanings of the verses, the sayings, conducts, silence and assertions of the Messenger of God (pbuh) and those of the ...
  • Does divine infinity mean that He is ambiguous?
    6267 Philosophy of Gnosis 2012/02/08
    Divine infinity does not signify mathematical and numerical infinity; rather it means absoluteness and possession of all attributes of perfection. Knowing the One God, as the most perfect being with the most perfect attributes and devoid of any imperfection and deficiency and understanding His relationship with the world which is ...
  • What is sex change?
    7331 احکام تغییر جنسیت 2012/08/23
    Although dictionaries do not provide a definition for "sex change", it means any change and transformation in a male, female or genderless in such a way that the current state is different from the previous one. Medically speaking, sex change is different from "genetic modification" ...
  • What is the time frame in which Dua Ahd should be read in?
    6947 Contextual study 2008/05/25
    It has been stated in traditions that whosoever recites this hadith for forty days in the morning, he/she will be one of the companions of Imam Zaman (a.s.) and …[1]. Conclusion: Dua Ahd needs to be read in the morning, and the best time ...
  • How is it possible to differentiate between someone who falsely claims to be a prophet and one who is a true prophet?
    5165 وحی 2017/05/22
    1. In Arabic, the term ‘wahy’ literally means giving a message quickly and secretly. In Islamic terminology, ‘wahy’ is the revealing or disclosing of some form of truth or knowledge through communication with Allah, with or without an intermediary. 2. Not only ‘wahy’ in its literal meaning ...
  • What is the ruling on having a relation with a non-mahram girl?
    8767 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/10/02
    Any form of relationship before marriage, let it be speaking intimately, touching and caressing etc. is haram. If one speaks with a girl with the intention of seeking pleasure or if he fears that he might fall into a sin with her, it is not permissible for him ...
  • If Islam is the religion of kindness and love what do the aggressive verses of the holy Quran stand for?!
    4561 دین اسلام 2019/10/06
  • What is Islam’s view on dinosaurs?
    26489 Exegesis 2007/02/26
                The Quran is a book of guidance and everything which supports this goal [of guidance] has been mentioned in this Holy Book. The method used in expressing matters is: focusing on the general aspects and less on the details and particulars, ...
  • Does Paradise have several gates and do those gates have specific names?
    8977 اوصاف بهشت و جهنم 2015/01/05
    Paradise has eight different gates. As for their names and what group of people use which gate to enter, there are different reports and traditions. Their names – such as Baab al-Rahmah (Gate of Mercy), Baab al-Sabr (Gate of Patience), Baab al-Shukr (Gate of Gratitude) Baab al-Balaa ...