Advanced search
Visit
5759
Last Updated: 2007/06/09
Summary of question
If Allah (s.w.t.) sends us back to this world after our death, would we become righteous people?
question
If we were to die, and would wish to come back to this world, and Allah was to grant this wish, would we be better people after coming back?
Concise answer

First of all, the returning of people to this world after death defeats the whole purpose of this universe’s creation and the appointment and sending of the prophets. Secondly, if by any chances people were to come back, there is no guarantee that they would be better, because the world they used to live in would be the same old world and they would be the same old people with the same temptations and desires they used to have. Just like before, they would know that these desires are all like a mirage, yet they would still fall in love with them and do any evil acts to reach these pleasures.

Detailed Answer

It is God’s will for everything to reach perfection and development in this world. He has created man in this world and supplied him with intellect and divine revelation in order for him to move towards perfection. Therefore, if people were to be allowed to return to this world after death according to their own will, the whole purpose of creating the universe and sending prophets would be defeated and such thing doesn’t comply with Allah’s norm and routine practice.

Moreover, there is no guarantee that such individuals will change for the better after returning, because they will be in the situation they were before; the same world, the same desires, pleasures, satanic desires, self-pride and rebellion. In other words, the same factors causing them to go astray and deny Allah’s signs today, will be there if they ever return, causing them to go astray once again.[1]

That is the reason behind why the Quran says: (In Falsehood will they be) Until, when death comes to one of them, he says: "O my Lord! send me back (to the world),-

"In order that I may work righteousness in the things I neglected." - "It isn’t so! It is but a word he says (and if he is returned he will be as he was before)."- Before them is a Partition till the Day they are raised up.[2]

What is important here and should be noted is that in response to their request, the word kalla (it isn’t so) is used. In Arabic literature, this word is used for two things:

1- preventing and not allowing something 2- annulling the opposite side’s argument and claim. There is a big chance that this verse is trying to get both meanings across at the same time with this single word. In this case, the verse’s meaning will go like this: First of all, their request is merely an excuse for returning, but such a thing is impossible. Secondly, their claim is a false one when they say that they will make up for the lost past and do righteous deeds. Allah says what they are saying isn’t true and that if they go back, they will be as they were before.[3] In addition to the fact that the word la’alla (meaning maybe) in the verse shows that even these individuals themselves aren’t sure about their own future if they come back and doubt that they will change and probably know that their regret and repentance is because of the fact that they are edging ever closer to death.[4]

Anyways, what is important is that returning is useless. Allah says in the holy Quran: “If they were returned (to this world) they would repeat the actions that they had been ordered not to commit”[5], therefore their awakening and being after the truth is only temporary and isn’t continuous.[6]

These people are like the kafirs and sinners who when getting stuck in a sea storm and get very close to death, ask Allah (s.w.t.) for help, yet after being saved, they return to the same state they were before. In other words, these people have most probably comprehended the fact that this world isn’t forever, and have seen death with their own eyes and yet they still lose their will when it comes to worldly pleasures and desires, and are ready to do anything, no matter how bad, in order to satisfy these desires.



[1] Al-Mizan, v.7, pg. 84.

[2]حتی اذا جاء احدهم الموت قال رب ارجعون. لعلی اعمل صالحاً فیما ترکت کلاّ انّها کلمة هو قائلها” Mo’minum:99-100

[3] See: Tafsir Nemooneh, v.14, pg. 313, Al-Mizan, v.5, pg.98.

[4] Tafsir al-Tebyan, v.7, pg.393, Kanz-ul-Irfan, v.9, pg.212.

[5]ولو رودا لعادوا لمانهوا عنه” An’am:28

[6] Tafsir Nemooneh, v.5, pg.200.

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • Is it possible to see God? If so, then how?
    6622 Traditional
    According to both Islamic sources and the intellect, God cannot be seen by the physical eye neither in this life nor in the next. However He can be seen through the eyes of the heart. Up to each given individual’s capacity, after purifying their souls, and engaging in prayers and ...
  • What are the “Arsh” and “Kursiyy”?
    11119 Exegesis
    With help from other Quranic verses and traditions of the imams, commentators of the Quran have presented several possible meanings for these terms. Some say the two are metaphorically referring to the same thing, which is the rank of Allah's (swt) command and governing of this world’s affairs.
  • Is Imam Ali capable of reviving the dead?
    8485 Exegesis
    Asserting that someone can independently do so without God’s assistance is in absolute contradiction with tawhid af’ali (oneness in action), for death and life is solely in God’s hand.However, if one were to carry out this act with God’s consent, it would then be considered probable and possible.
  • Was Ibn Arabi Shia or Sunni?
    14761 تاريخ بزرگان
    The complicated personality and his attitude towards different great personalities of different sects has made it difficult to determine what sect Ibn Arabi belonged to, thus there are different viewpoints on this issue. Some say he was Sunni, some say he was a twelve imamer Shia, some say ...
  • What is sex change?
    6097 احکام تغییر جنسیت
    Although dictionaries do not provide a definition for "sex change", it means any change and transformation in a male, female or genderless in such a way that the current state is different from the previous one. Medically speaking, sex change is different from "genetic modification" ...
  • Why do some people oppose mysticism and the mystics making reference to ahadith (traditions)?
    5742 دین و عرفان
    Irfan (mysticism/ Gnosticism) has been defined as a special method to reach the realities of existence and to connect man to truth, which is done through vision and intuition. Such an understanding depends on practice and special asceticism. The practical methods or what is known as ‘wayfaring ...
  • Why aren’t the Imams’ names clearly mentioned in the Quran?
    8593 Traditional
    We must pay attention that even though the Imams’ names are not mentioned in the Quran, but they have been clearly mentioned in the words of the Prophet, especially Imam Ali. The most prominent example of this would be the hadith of Ghadir that is deemed as the ...
  • What is the Islamic law about smoking cigarette or hookah?
    6817 Laws and Jurisprudence
    Ayatollah Mahdi Hadavi Tehrani's opinion regarding the foregoing question is as under: "Smoking tobacco (cigarettes and hookah) is absolutely haram because it is injurious to health."It should be noted that the jurisprudential argument of the verdict of Ayatollah Mahdi Hadavi Tehrani concerning the ...
  • Is there any problem in sweeping and cleaning one”s house at night?
    68908 Hadith
    1. Having conducted a research into Hadith (scriptural) sources, we found out that the narrations about cleaning, dusting and sweeping a house are absolute and unrestricted in the sense that they include both day and night. There is nothing to indicate that dusting and cleaning are forbidden ...
  • Could you provide me with the complete sermon of the Holy Prophet (s) at Ghadir Khum?
    6840 Traditional
    This question doesn’t have a brief answer. Please click on the detailed answer. ...

Popular